Hi @user1637, ugh, that is a frown. (I am going to leave a couple of links at the bottom of this reply, I think don’t they’ll help you immediately, just good background on cloudflare & wordpress)
I found a couple of similar issues, but with no definite resolution indicated. Diagnosis was a cached DNS record and solution was to wait. The tickets did not indicate if that cache was on an intermediate proxy or local. Will keep digging.
Here are those background links I mentioned I’d share: