Why are all Freenom domains giving an error when trying to add them?

I keep seeing the same generic response pasted in every Freenom-related thread and it doesn’t really seem to make sense. From what I can see, Freenom is correctly responding to whois requests and there’s zero reason those domains shouldn’t be able to be added at this time.

For example, a user posted yesterday that they couldn’t add lifestealrealm.ml due to the error.

But Freenom’s whois is responding to it:

whois lifestealrealm.ml

% IANA WHOIS server
% for more information on IANA, visit http://www.iana.org
% This query returned 1 object

refer:        whois.dot.ml

domain:       ML

organisation: Agence des Technologies de l’Information et de la Communication
address:      ACI 2000 Hamdallaye
address:      Bamako BP E 5467
address:      Mali

contact:      administrative
name:         Chef Service Gestion du .ml
organisation: Agence des Technologies de l’Information et de la Communication
address:      ACI 2000 Hamdallaye
address:      Bamako BP E 5467
address:      Mali
phone:        +223 77 28 52 51
fax-no:       +223 20 29 94 13
e-mail:       [email protected]

contact:      technical
name:         Manager ICT
organisation: Mali Dili B.V.
address:      Keizersgracht 213
address:      1016 DT  Amsterdam
address:      Netherlands
phone:        +31 20 5315726
fax-no:       +31 20 5315721
e-mail:       [email protected]

nserver:      A.NS.ML 185.21.168.1 2a04:1b00:0:0:0:0:0:1
nserver:      B.NS.ML 185.21.169.1 2a04:1b00:1:0:0:0:0:1
nserver:      C.NS.ML 185.21.170.1 2a04:1b00:2:0:0:0:0:1
nserver:      D.NS.ML 185.21.171.1 2a04:1b00:3:0:0:0:0:1

whois:        whois.dot.ml

status:       ACTIVE
remarks:      Registration information: http://www.dot.ml

created:      1993-09-29
changed:      2018-04-20
source:       IANA

   
   Domain name:
      LIFESTEALREALM.ML

   Organisation:
      Mali Dili B.V.
      Point ML administrator
      P.O. Box 11774
      1001 GT  Amsterdam
      Netherlands
      Phone: +31 20 5315725
      Fax: +31 20 5315721
      E-mail: abuse: [email protected], copyright infringement: [email protected]

   Domain Nameservers:
      G.NS.ARVANCDN.CO
      X.NS.ARVANCDN.ORG


   Your selected domain name is a Free Domain. That means that,
   according to the terms and conditions of Free Domain domain names
   the registrant is Mali Dili B.V.

   Due to restrictions in Point ML 's Privacy Statement personal information
   about the user of the domain name cannot be released.

   ABUSE OF A DOMAIN NAME
   If you want to report abuse of this domain name, please send a
   detailed email with your complaint to [email protected]
   In most cases Point ML responds to abuse complaints within one business day.

   COPYRIGHT INFRINGEMENT
   If you want to report a case of copyright infringement, please send
   an email to [email protected], and include the full name and address of
   your organization. Within 5 business days copyright infringement notices
   will be investigated.

   Record maintained by: Point ML Domain Registry

You can also dig the nameservers:

dig +short ns lifestealrealm.ml

g.ns.arvancdn.co.
x.ns.arvancdn.org.

As well as a valid SOA:

dig +short soa lifestealrealm.ml

g.ns.arvancdn.co. hostmaster.arvancloud.com. 1636231999 86400 7200 604800 7200.   

Running a trace works properly on https://www.digwebinterface.com/ too.

In fact, you can even enter that domain on CF’s Diagnostic Center here:
Diagnostic Center | Check SSL and Test Website Security | Cloudflare

Even there it’s able to find the nameservers because it gives the non_cloudflare_nameservers error instead of showing no_nameservers like it does when NS don’t exist.

I’ve tried this across multiple domains, with and without valid nameservers as well as ones with different or non-existent SOA and A records. None of them can be added to Cloudflare.

Can someone clarify why Cloudflare thinks this is an issue with Freenom’s whois?

This topic was automatically closed 15 days after the last reply. New replies are no longer allowed.