Unable to Authenticate with Google

Hi all, I would like to authenticate using Google. I followed the instructions to do so on the Cloudflare portal, copy/pasted my client ID and secret, but when I test it, I receive this error:

"Failed to get your identity

Looks like something went wrong. Here are the details.

User email was not returned. API permissions are likely incorrect.

{

“id”: “[My Google ID]”,

“name”: “[My name associated with the Google Account]”

}"

Any thoughts on what the issue might be?