Just choose the setting you want manually, automatic setting will track what your origin is capable of.
However “Flexible” and “Full” are legacy modes and not secure and so you should set and use “Full (strict)” ensuring you have a valid SSL certificate on your origin server.
For ■■■■’s sake, make it easier to report a bug! I don’t need support I just wanted to report a bug.
For some reason, the SSL/TLS settings where put to FULL instead of Flexible. And it crushed two of my websites. And it did not happen all at once, a few days ago first site failed, today the second one.
This is ridiculous because that’s the whole point of using Cloudflare
You would have previously enabled the SSL recommender, so the auto selection takes over. That Cloudflare changed the mode indicates your origin did respond favourably when Cloudflare tested what modes can be supported.
If you don’t want Cloudflare to automatically set the mode, then set it manually. But do use “Full (strict)”.