% dig +short yubigeek.com @nina.ns.cloudflare.com.
Are the nameservers at the bottom of your DNS tab
walt.ns.cloudflare.com? If they are, then you have a bug, as the DNS requests are not returning the Cloudflare IP. If they are not, then you are looking at the wrong account.
Try turning it off and on again, but you should open a support case.
To contact Cloudflare Customer Support, login & go to https://dash.cloudflare.com/?account=support and select get more help. If you receive an automatic response that does not help you, please reply and indicate you need more help.