From the screenshot above and as I have checked using DIG, and as far as you want to use vote.variamc.net as stated in a Page Rule, it seems to me like there is no A vote DNS record configured and added for your domain name
there is only A play, CNAME variamc.net and CNAME www
Kindly double-check and re-add a new DNS record:
A vote pointed to 192.0.2.1 and to make it work
Upon you add it, please wait for a few minutes to apply the changes.
Also, you can try to open vote.variamc.net in a different Web browser.
Helpful article with the step-by-step instructions how to add a new DNS record:
Helpful articles about using Page Rules for forwarding/redirect: