Make sure it is the IP assigned to your website. Some hosting providers will give you different IPs for ftp, mail, http etc.
Also, you should go back and edit the previous msg to remove or re-upload the image with the IP addresses obfuscated. We should avoid making public the IP addresses of our sites, lest some hackers find them and try to attack the site directly, thus bypassing Cloudflare protections.
One thing is clear about your setup. It is working as far as sending requests to your domain to Cloudflare. You an check this by going to your domain with Dev Tools open (Ctrl-Shift-J on Windows for most browsers). On the Network tab you’ll see a header CF-Ray, with the Ray ID assigned by Cloudflare, as well as the header Server: Cloudflare.
So the problem must be somewhere between Cloudflare and your server. I hope others in this Community of volunteers may help you further debug the problem.
@domjh @sdayman @Judge