Moreover, your A record www and A recordglattkosherstore.com points to IP address (216.117.144.132) and is obviously . They should be both on at your Cloudflare dashboard.
You simply need to turn the root and www records in your DNS Dashboard.
Either you do not have an SSL certificate or it is invalid at your host/origin.
None of the common names in the certificate match your domain (neither www):
diamondfringe.com www.diamondfringe.com
Common name: www.israelikosher.com
SANs: www.israelikosher.com, israelikosher.com
And the certificate is not signed by a trusted authority.
Due to not being proxied via Cloudflare, neither the certificate covers your domain, you also have mixed-content errors.