Because your domain does not use Cloudflare name servers, any changes you’re trying to make through Cloudflare won’t propagate at all.
Contact your authoritative DNS provider, - which seems to be Go Daddy (with the two name servers, ns19.domaincontrol.com and ns20.domaincontrol.com), and ask them for further advice on how to set up the mentioned DNS record(s) from their end.
We’ve already tried authenticating other platforms such as Constant Contact and ClickFunnels with no problem at all. We only encounter much delay with Followup Boss.
They are actually the same records. One was added manually. The other was via automation (Entri). I already deleted the latter, which no space/s. Im not really sure what exactly is the error, since as you’ve mentioned, everything looks exactly configured. But, the FUB still isn’t authenticated even after redoing it for the nth time.
According to the Internet standards, the space(s) between the “key=value” pairs, as in your example, shouldn’t matter.
However, if it was in the middle of a value, e.g. “k=r sa” instead of “k=rsa”, things would likely break.
That said, -
Bad implementations have been seen before, - so I won’t be able to guarantee how strict Follow Up Boss’s (or anyone else’s) systems may have been made, in regards to that, and whether they break with (or without) them.