As mentioned, the record is proxied so returns Cloudflare IP addresses. If you want to see the record as entered, then you need to switch the record to “DNS only” instead of “Proxied”. Note that then requests will go direct to your host and not pass through Cloudflare so no Cloudflare protections or features will be applied to your traffic.
I just switched the domain from Proxied to “DNSo only” and will check it with my website host and provider.
But, the interesting point is that the other domain has the same " Proxied" setup and does not have any problems. https://smartbusinessbuilders.com.au/
Please tell me why.
Now, I saw the error message as follows, and I will double-check with them:
Your connection is not private
Attackers might be trying to steal your information from smartbusinessbuilderspro.com (for example, passwords, messages or credit cards). Learn more about this warning
It won’t be showing the IP address of your origin publicly then as it returns proxied IP addresses as your new site did. Are you sure the proxied record is the “problem”?