Thanks for your response! I’ve attached a screenshot of my Cloudflare portal, please let me know if you find an error. I also double-checked that it was the same IP address from my Bluehost hosting account (also attached).
So far as I can tell from using DNSchecker, the DNS records are still pointing to Cloudflare’s servers rather than Bluehost’s server address. Please correct me if I’m wrong about this, and I appreciate your help!
Your DNS as seen from the outside world will always resolve to Cloudflare IP addresses; this is normal and is how Cloudflare works. What’s important is the address it really points to, which in your case looks correct.
The 403 error your site is returning is coming from your origin server. Since this is in fact the correct server, something at that end is not configured properly. It could be that the server is not configured to answer to the getscholarly.ai domain. It could be something as simple as not having an index.html file in the root of the server directory.
What we do know is that the problem isn’t your DNS and isn’t at Cloudflare.