cPanel AutoSSL and Cloudflare issue

Having a bit of an issue with AutoSSL and Cloudflare.

My site’s SSL certificate expired yesterday (Jan 14th) so I do what I always do: Disable Cloudflare, run AutoSSL, re-enable Cloudflare. This has always worked in the past.

While it appears to have updated the certificate correctly, for some reason AutoSSL keeps trying to run (you can see it tried running today, the 15th) and is giving me an error message.

A picture speaks a thousand words:

Not sure why it would keep trying to run if it was updated? Any ideas here?

As an aside, since I use the SSL provided by Cloudflare anyway, can I simply just disable AutoSSL?

Thanks in advance for any help!