Changing records from AWS to Hostgator shows maintenance page


We have GoDaddy as our registrar, Cloudflare as our nameserver/dns and yesterday we changed Cloudflare records, removing AWS (our website) to Hostgator (new website).
All we can see is the “There is a new page coming soon” from Hostgator.

Question: Could this issue be on Cloudflare side? Or is it 100% related to Hostgator?

Those records are :grey: which means DNS only, no other Cloudflare service involved other than DNS resolution. Assuming you’ve typed the IP address correctly it’s 100% not Cloudflare.