I followed the wizard and changed my nameservers to the Cloudflare ones and now my website msinevitable.com is unreachable. It has been 24 hours and the email says active. The error on site load says too many redirects (ERR_TOO_MANY_REDIRECTS).
There are no longer any DNS records in my namecheap account since I pointed them to Cloudflare. Not sure if it helps but my domain is in namecheap and used to point to my hostgator hosting.
Everything was working fine until I changed the DNS to the Cloudflare suggested ones last night.
These are the Cloudflare nameservers |NS|nicole.ns.cloudflare.com|