Testing my free plan website, CF simply doesn’t provision an RSA certificate for it anymore (only an ECDSA certificate). ECDSA is arguably more secure than RSA and should work fine with Apple Pay.
I highly recommend testing apple pay’s “sandbox mode” without changing anything at Cloudflare to see how well it works using elliptic curve instead of RSA.
Thanks @Judge. Unfortunately, as far as I can tell, there’s no access to their sandbox until they verify your domain by confirming the cipher, which is a bit of a catch22.
Has anyone else solved this issue by upgrading to the Pro plan?